AdmitMBA360 Blog formerly Journey to my MBA

Journey to my MBA

Wednesday, August 09, 2006

BusinessWeek Article: You Don't have to Wait

B-Schools: You Don't Have to Wait
At many programs, having four to six years of work experience is no longer a prerequisite for gaining admission

When Jonathan Bankard decided to apply to Harvard Business School last year, the Brown University senior heard the same thing from pretty much everyone: "You won't get in." After all, they told him, everybody knows you need years of full-time work experience to get into business school.

But Bankard, who had worked or interned every summer since he was 13, been a teacher's assistant at two business courses at Brown, and founded his own startup tech company, figured he might as well give it a shot, and his parents—and ultimately, Harvard—agreed.

Bankard's father had himself gone straight from undergrad to Harvard Business School back in 1966, when close to a third of his classmates did so as well. Things have changed a bit since then: Not only do Harvard B-schoolers no longer wear suits to class but students straight out of college make up only about 1% of enrollment there and at most other top programs, where the average student has between four and six years of work experience. But that might not be the case for long (see 2/13/06, "Who Needs the Real World?").

MORE ISN'T BETTER. While undergrads applying to B-school is hardly a new phenomenon, now more top schools, including Harvard, Stanford Wharton, and Chicago are making a greater effort to reach out to "early career" applicants with less than three years of work experience, including students like Bankard who apply directly from undergraduate programs. And contrary to what many applicants believe, even schools like Tuck and Kellogg that don't accept undergrads say that while some work experience is critical, more isn't always better.

Admissions directors say their efforts are an attempt to correct a trend ongoing for the last decade and a half, during which increased competition in MBA admissions helped push the average years of work experience at top schools from around three years to five.

And while the number of college seniors admitted to top B-schools will likely remain a tiny percentage of the total (the University of Rochester is one exception), many admissions directors hope the renewed focus on younger applicants will eventually help expand the entire applicant pool by bringing in more people (and in particular, more women) applying one to three years into their careers (see, 2/13/06, "Skip the Résumé").

SLOW TO CATCH UP. Recent demographic and sociological trends have made expanding the applicant pool an increasingly important issue in B-school admissions offices. The overall number of applications to MBA programs has declined for several years, and full-time MBA programs have seen the biggest drop (see, 8/9/05, "MBA Applications: Still Skidding").The age distribution in the U.S. is changing as well: 20- to 24-year-olds already make up a greater percentage of the population than they did 10 years ago.

The applicant pool, however, has been slow to catch up. In the 1990s, as business schools got more competitive and the booming economy offered more opportunities, many people started delaying their applications for a few years in the hope of boosting their chances.

The increasingly competitive environment also gave B-schools an incentive to up their average years of work experience, because doing so helped raise average salaries upon graduation. "The word on the street became: 'B-schools will only be interested in you if you have five years of work experience,' " says Brit Dewey of Harvard Business School. And although that belief has since become ingrained, admissions directors say just it just isn't true.

Paul Danos, Dean of Dartmouth's Tuck School of Business, says that even at Tuck, where general practice requires at least two years of full-time experience (except for students in the combined MD/MBA program), having fewer than the average number of years is not a disadvantage.

"A person with three great years of experience has just as good a chance as someone with five," he says. "It's not so much the number of years, it's what they've achieved."

ADVANTAGES. Applying earlier often carries benefits for individuals. Since early-career applicants generally draw smaller salaries than they will later in their careers, a break for B-school is less of a financial sacrifice. And, especially for women, it reduces the chances that career and family will be put in direct conflict (see, 12/1/04, "Breaking B-School Gender Barriers").

Encouraging students to pursue their MBA earlier in their careers can be a boon for companies as well. At Chicago, for example, early-career initiatives were spurred by appeals from the school's corporate partners concerned about retaining their top talent. Director of Admissions Rose Martinelli spent this summer talking to top consulting and investment banking firms about encouraging their entry-level analysts to apply to business school after working for two or three years, instead of going elsewhere first to gain more experience.

And Bolton notes that some companies, like Proctor & Gamble (PG), actually prefer to hire MBAs with only a few years of work experience, before they've been molded to another company's corporate culture. "When you're trying to serve a diverse group of companies, having a diverse group of students is a real benefit," he says.

One place where attitudes are changing is Penn's Wharton School. Thomas Caleel, who was appointed as Wharton's director of MBA admissions and financial aid last year, says that under his predecessors, Wharton wasn't very welcoming to candidates with less than four years of work experience—a philosophy that "didn't make a lot of sense," he says.

Although Wharton had always admitted a few Wharton undergrads per year through the school's submatriculation program, just 1% of students in Wharton's MBA class of 2007 had two or fewer years of work experience. Under Caleel's leadership, that percentage has already risen to 3% for the class of 2008.

B-SCHOOLS' HARD SELL. Caleel has traveled extensively over the past year to get the word out to undergraduates that there's no "right time" to apply to business school—and he's not the only one. When Stanford's director of MBA admissions started five years ago, Stanford made five to six college visits a year. This year the school will be doing nearly 100.

At Carnegie Mellon's Tepper School of Business, Executive Admissions Director Laurie Stewart says the school has "reinvigorated" its longstanding 3-2 program, which allows Carnegie Mellon undergrads to earn their BA and MBA in five years, by actively recruiting on campus. About 5% of Tepper's MBAs now come the through the 3-2 program.

And at Virginia's Darden School, Interim Director of Admissions Everette Fortner says the business school has recently renewed its efforts to build relationships with its undergraduate feeder schools. This spring, Darden invited career counselors from 10 schools to come to campus and learn about Darden and business schools in general.

The University of Texas McCombs School of Business also quietly did away with its two-year work experience requirement for students last year. Although the school still "strongly recommends" two years of work for most applicants, it has opened the doors to a small number of high-achieving undergraduates through the newly created McCombs Scholar program.

While some critics worry that applicants without significant work experience are unprepared for top MBA programs (see, 2/13/06, "Degreed but Unprepared") many admissions directors say that younger students have a lot to bring to the table, especially since today's students graduate college with much more compelling internships, leadership roles, and entrepreneurial experience than students just a decade ago.

Several schools now offer college seniors special accommodations during the admissions process in order to make applying as "risk-free" as possible. Harvard, Chicago, and MIT waive their admissions fee for all college seniors, and Stanford waives the fee to any senior receiving financial aid.

Both Stanford and Harvard offer one-on-one feedback to any college students who are not admitted, so they can learn how to improve their application for the next time. This year, Stanford says that college seniors will be interviewed by admissions staffers, rather than alumni, who may be unsure about how to evaluate such students.

PUT IT OFF. Yet some admissions officers admit that even the most academically gifted students may not be ready to begin an MBA program. Deferred admission is another way schools are allowing top-notch undergrads into their programs without sacrificing work experience.

Harvard has historically admitted 10 to 20 students per year on a deferred basis, and recently Stanford started granting deferrals to admitted college seniors as well. MIT currently accepts six students per year through the StartingBloc program, aimed at budding social entrepreneurs, and gives students the option of matriculating immediately or deferring for up to two years.

In 2005, McCombs launched a new deferred admission program called Jump Start for students who are academically qualified but in need of work experience. Companies including Deloitte Consulting and JPMorgan Chase [] (JPM ) agree to hire the students for three years, and McCombs offers candidates deferred admission to the MBA program.

Admissions directors say that planting the seed early—speaking to college students about business school before they have made their big career decisions—is a way to pull in more applicants who might not have otherwise considered B-school. It also sends a message to applicants that more experience doesn't necessarily provide a competitive edge. "When you say you can come straight from undergrad, you see more people who feel they can apply at two years out," says Bolton.

The real message for B-school applicants: Don't let a shorter-than-average résumé discourage you from applying. Most admissions directors would agree that it's quality, not quantity, that counts.


Anonymous Poor Boy said...

For my part, I'd rather go to school with people who have some life experience in the real world. Part of what I'm paying for when I go to Business School is my peers, I need to be with people who've been in the thick of things, who know how things work and who have something to add based n their participation in the business world. The difference between the quality of discussion in an undergraduate business management class, and a graduate management class should be night-and-day. My $0.02.

12:21 PM  
Blogger Nat4mba said...

I completely agree with poor boy: it can be a great headache to share a classroom with an unexperienced fresh graduate. At the same time, discussing business cases and other matters with a graduate with outstandingly strong academic knowledge is also a valuable experience. During my postgraduate studies I definitely felt more pain in dealing with experienced but narrow-minded people than with scholars. Of course, Adcoms' big job is to keep the highest standard in both cases.

2:05 AM  
Blogger Dave for MBA said...

The article provided an example of someone who had been working part time through a good portion of their academic life. I too am like that. Moreover, I too feel that I would have been a good candidate if I had considered Business School at that time. However, I see your points as well Poor Boy & Nat4mba as very valid reasons. Three colleges that clearly seek undergraduate transition people are Wharton, Harvard and Stanford. Knowing this, would you still not apply to these schools?

I think you're points are mostly valid if 30% or more the students have less than 1 year of working experience. That would be really messed up. But if say 5% of the class were youngins, then I don't think I'd mind all that much.

8:30 AM  
Blogger Nat4mba said...

Dave, as I said in my post, a really good scholar can be worth two short-sighted businessmen, in my opinion. If I were asked, I would definitely choose to study with a PhD with zero corporate experience instead of a small business-narrow niche enterpreneur. I just read about Wharton's statistics: it is said that this year the school admitted twice as many people of 0 to 2 years of experience than last year. Twice! I guess, it can exceed 5%. Though I don't want to be snobbish...

7:14 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well, I finished the Exec MBA course at Cranfield last December. With 10+ years I'm fairly experienced.

You learn as much from other students as you do from the faculty- so having a class rich in experience is key.

I understand that the full-timers at Cranfield have a similar experience.

4:16 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home

Journey to my MBA Locations of visitors to this page
Stay up to date with this Blog
Monitor changes to links on the sidebars of this Web Site
Dave's E-Mail

Subscribe with Bloglines Subscribe with My Yahoo! Subscribe with Google Subscribe in NewsGator Online Subscribe in Rojo Subscribe with Pluck RSS reader Subscribe with Bloglines Add to AOL
Get Updates of this Blog via Email:

Powered by
Some Noteworthy Blog Postings
Cornell-Johnson Visit Experience-Dave
MIT-Sloan Visit Experience-Dave
Wharton Visit Experience-Dave
Darden Visit Experience-'04-Dave
Darden Visit/Interview Experience-'06-Dave
Darden Pictures-'06
HBS Visit Experience-'04-Dave
HAAS Visit/Info Session-'04-Dave
Columbia Visit/Info Session-'04-Axechick
Tuck Visit/Info Session-'05-Laser
Tuck Visit/Interview '06-Dave
Tuck Pictures1-'06
Tuck Pictures2-'06
Michigan Info Sess. Experience-Dave
Columba Info Sess. Experience-Dave
Tuck Info Sess. Experience-Dave
World MBA Tour Experience-Dave
Travel Guides-Dave
Columbia Open House I-Droodoggie
Columbia Open House II-Droodoggie
Application Essay Advice-Dave
Application Essay Advice II-Dave
MBA App advice-Consulting/Management-Dave
Good Essay question Prep-Uniqpath
The MBA Journey Begins-Dave
The MBA App Process-MarketWiz
Picking Target Schools-Sghama
Pre-App Tips-Bloghorn8
How to interact w/ B-School Staff-Dave
Managing Your Recommenders-ClearAdmit
Schools I Picked & Why-Anand
Import App Elements-Redwolf056
A Successful Essay(Chicago GSB)-PowerYogi
Why Chicago GSB-Paul Jan
Stanford GSB Dean on Essays
------------------ Application Process ------------------
Advice on Admissions Consultants-Dave
Why get an MBA now?-Dave
Why do I need an MBA?-Dave
Story of Tenacity-Dave
MBA App Advice-Dave
Maximize your MBA Info Sess. Exp.-Dave
Low GPA Stories-Dave
Introspect on being resolute-Dave
Why Attitude Matters-Dave
Wharton's Interview Policy-RedWolf
Dealing with a Low GPA
Tuck's App Review Process
UCLA's App Review Process
Wharton's App Review Process
Every Essay Tells a Story
Your Story is so Interesting
What is a great essay?
Am I too young to apply?
When is the best time to apply?
Applying and not sure where to start?
Is school XXX any good?
The B-School Admit Hate List
Hey Applicant, Lay off the Buggin
Should I interview on or off campus?(See comment)
MBA Tour/Info Session Tip
The Interview
------------------ GMAT ----------------------------------
Low GMAT Success Stories
GMAT Score Needed in Europe
GMAT Score Needed
GMAT Score Needed by Age
GMAT Score Needed by Country
GMAT Score Needed by Race
GMAT Score Needed by Major
Budgeting time for the GMAT
Breaking the 700 Barrier
The B-School Route to Career Change
Pre-MBA Resources
MBA Math Build math and spreadsheet skills
MBA Resources show all
--------- Video Interview's of B-School Deans -------
Video Interviews of B-School Deans
------------ B-School Visit Experiences ----------------
Admin Director Interviews
Visit Reviews
------------ MBA Forums ----------------------------------
Business Week Forum
Wharton Student Forum
Chicago GSB Forum
Yale Forum

----------- B-School Articles and News-----------------
How B-Schools get their name
BusinessWeek(B-School Headlines)
The Economist(News from Schools)
The Financial Times(Business Education)
Wall Street Journal(MBA Center)
----------- Gen MBA Info ---------------------------------
MBABuzz MBA Blogs, Forum, App Stat Plotter
MBA Info
MBA Studylink
MBA Jungle
MBA Game Plan
MBA Official Guide
MBA Depot
Top 10 MBA
Ivy League
MBA Podcaster
MBA Jargon
MBA School Directory
MBA 4 Success
Military MBA

------------ MBA Program Summary for Applicants---
ClearAdmit School Guides
WSJ School Snapshots
WSJ Who's Recruiting Where?
MBAPrepAdvantage School Profiles
------------ MBA Foreign Related -----------------------
Canadian MBA
Infozee "Foreign MBA"
------------ MBA Conf/Foundations --------------------
The MBA Tour
The MBA Diversity Alliance
Forte Foundation
Catalyst Women
Knowledge@Wharton Podcast
Association of MBAs
------------ Resume Help ---------------------------------
Darden Resume's
MBA Game Plan Resume Help

------------ Essay Help ------------------------------------
American Dream - (Dave's Pick) (Samples) (Getting Started)
MBA Essay Strategy(download)
MBA Game Plan Essay Help
Some Classic Advice from Wharton Boards
Clear Edit Automated writing editor
MBA Studio

------------- Interview Insight --------------------------
B-School Interview Braindump-Accepted
B-School Interview Braindump-Clearadmit
------------- Ethnocentric Assoc. ----------------------
LEAD Program for minorities
------------- Post-MBA ------------------------------------
MBA Concepts
------------- MBA Articles---------------------------------
If you want your application to B-School to stand out;first do your homework properly, and then apply early
Admissions Tip:HBS Essay #2
Writing good essays from an ADCOM perspective
Top 5 MBA programs Article
The Full-Time Advantage
Overcoming Procrastination
Why B-School is good for our Economy

MBA Ranks show all
Ranks by Industry Sector Show
Forbes ranking measures the graduates' return on investment
Economist ranking reports how students and alumni rated their MBA experience
BusinessWeek surveys students and corporate recruiters and measures intellectual capital
Wall Street Journal is a corporate recruiter based poll (21 criteria)
U.S. News & World Report evals student selectivity and placement data and gathers the perceptions of deans and program directors to develop the ranking
Financial Times poll measures career progression of alumni, program diversity and a school's track record in producing new ideas in management
BusinessWeek '06 Rank
BusinessWeek '06 Slideshow
Financial Times '08 (PDF) (Interactive)
US News&World Report 2009
Economist 2008 Rankings
------Wall Street Journal Rankings--------------------
WSJ 2006(US)
WSJ 2006(International)
WSJ 2006(Academic Discipline)
WSJ 2006(Women)
WSJ 2006(Ethics)
WSJ 2006(Minorities)
WSJ 2006(Industry)
Forbes Rankings 05' Results - 07' Results Rankings
Beyond Grey Pinstripes 2009
DTU Research per School
B-School Research Rankings
Financial Times E-MBA Rankings '06 PDF
BusinessWeek E-MBA Rankings '05
Money's top 100 MBA Employers '06
US News Category Ranks '06
Financial Times Category Ranks
Asia B-School Rank 2000
Australian 2005 Financial Review
German B-School Rank
Computerworld top techno MBA Survey
Consus Group B-School Rankings top 100 Entrepreneurial Colleges
Find MBA Rankings
International Education Commission's Top 10
Marr/Kirkwood Comparison Rankings
Official MBA Guide:MBA Program Ranking and Screening

GMAT Resources show all
GMAC-Register for GMAT
---------- GMAT Articles ----------------------------------
GMAT 700+ Stories(download)
Why Prepare?
About the GMAT
How someone got a 760 score
How someone got a 790 score
Mark Rice GMAT Advice
Low GMAT Success Stories

---------- GMAT Forums ----------------------------------
Beat the GMAT
GMAT Club Forum and Files!
TestMagic Forum

---------- GMAT Companies ------------------------------
Bell Curves
GMAX Online(Online GMAT Course)
Manhattan GMAT
Perfect GMAT
Princeton Review
Test Prep New York
Test Prep Review(Online Course)
Veritas GMAT Prep
790GMAT GMAT Guru(SF based)

---------- GMAT Self Study Guides ----------------------
Corrections to Official Guide 11th
Advanced GMAT Math Study Guide
GMAT Study Strategy
Micro Edu GMAT Prep Material
Probability Review(download)
4GMAT - Math Books (India)

---------- GMAT Resource/Reference -----------------
GMAT Scratchpad
Dr Math
Dr Math-Pascal Triangle
GMAT Official Guide Question Info
Manhattan GMAT Study Guides (Dave's Pick) (Math Skills Review)
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary
Texas A&M-College Algebra
The Math Page (For Basic Math Skills)
101 Basic Radical & Exponent Review

---------- GMAT Tests ------------------------------------
PowerPrep GMAT CAT (Dave's Pick)
Ascent Education
800 Score (Dave's Pick)
English Test
GMAT Practice Tests
Gorilla Test Prep
Manhattan GMAT Tests (Dave's Pick)
R&B Consulting Prep Software
ScoreTop Online Verbal-Quant Tests
TestPrep New York
Upstart Raising GMAT Simulator

Financing your MBA show all
Financial Aid Podcast
Fundsnet-Search Engine
Graduate Fellowship Database info
Sallie Mae-MBA Loans
US Government's E-Scholar
MBA Admission Consultants show all Forum
Brody Admissions
Cambridge Essay Service
Clear Admit
Essay Solutions
Global Now
Maxx Associates
MBA Apply
The MBA Exchange
MBAGameplan Article
MBA Studio
Stacy Blackman
Veritas Consulting
-------- Brazilian Admin Consultants ------------------
MBA Empresarial
-------- Commentary on Admin Consultants ----------
Why use them?
Comments about some of them
Not all Consultants are good
MBA Life show all
Chicago GSB Online Newspaper
Chicago GSB Magazine
Columbia B-School Wkly Online NewsPaper
Columbia Spectator Daily NewsPaper
Cornell Univ. Daily Sun (Main Campus)
Cornell Daily News Service Highlights
Dartmouth Online Newspaper
Tuck Today Online Happenings
Duke News & Community
HAAS Weekly
Harvard B-School Online Newspaper
Harvard Gazette Online Newspaper
Harvard Online Magazine
Kellogg Online Newspaper
News at MIT
Michigan(Ross) Newspaper
Texas McCombs Weekly
Michigan Daily Online Newspaper
Stern Online Newspaper
Stanford Online Newspaper
Stanford B-School Reporter
UCLA Qrtrly Assets Mag
Univ. Virginia Daily Online News
Wharton Online Newspaper
Yale Daily Online Newspaper
Yale Herald Online Newspaper
Blog & Other Resources show all
IQ Test
Computer Interval Clock
T-Mobile Coverage Check
Picasa Send large files Send large files
Understanding Blog Template Code
SSI Developer - CSS Monitor
Fodey.comNewspaperclip generator
MBA Related Books
Search Now:

Site Meter